The Best Christmas Songs for a Mixtape (Beyond the Usual Ones)
Everyone has heard the same ten Christmas songs a thousand times. These are the ones that make a mixtape feel like someone truly chose it.
It happens every December. You walk into a shop, and the same song is playing that was playing in the last shop, and the one before that. By the middle of the month, even the people who love Christmas music start to tune it out.
A mixtape is the cure. The best Christmas mixtape songs are rarely the ones on every radio station. They are the songs that make someone stop and ask what this is, and then ask you to play it again.
Here are the underrated Christmas songs worth putting on a CD or a cassette this year, grouped by mood, and a few ideas for turning them into a gift.
Why the usual Christmas songs wear thin
There is nothing wrong with the classics. The problem is repetition. When a song follows you from the supermarket to the office party, it stops feeling like yours.
A good mixtape works the other way. It feels chosen, and that is the whole point of what makes a good mixtape in the first place. Two or three familiar songs are fine as anchors. The rest should be discoveries.
There is also something personal in going beyond the obvious. Anyone can press play on a holiday playlist. Choosing songs that the other person has never heard, and that you think they will love, says that you know their taste and took the time to look further.
Soul and R&B that never got enough airplay
Start with warmth. "This Christmas" by Donny Hathaway, from 1970, has a groove that makes it sound less like a holiday song and more like a great soul record that happens to mention December.
"Gee Whiz, It's Christmas" by Carla Thomas, from 1963, is bright and a little playful. "Please Come Home for Christmas" by Charles Brown, from 1960, is the opposite: slow, bluesy and lonely in the best way. Stevie Wonder's "What Christmas Means to Me", from 1967, closes the set with pure joy.
The new wave and punk side of December
If the person you are making this for grew up in the late seventies or eighties, this section is for them. "Christmas Wrapping" by The Waitresses, from 1981, is a funny, wordy story about a woman who gives up on Christmas and finds love at the all-night store.
"2000 Miles" by The Pretenders, from 1983, is one of the most beautiful winter songs ever recorded, and it is about missing someone who is far away. The Kinks' "Father Christmas", from 1977, has a sharp sense of humor, and the Ramones' "Merry Christmas (I Don't Want to Fight Tonight)" is short, loud and surprisingly sweet. Jona Lewie's "Stop the Cavalry", from 1980, was never even meant to be a Christmas song, yet it became one.
Quiet Christmas playlist songs for late at night
Every Christmas mixtape needs a slower stretch, the songs for after the guests have gone. Joni Mitchell's "River", from her 1971 album Blue, begins with a few notes of "Jingle Bells" and then turns into one of the saddest, most honest songs about the season.
"Christmas Time Is Here" by the Vince Guaraldi Trio, from 1965, sounds like snow falling outside a window. "Just Like Christmas" by Low, from 1999, is short and dreamy. Ron Sexsmith's "Maybe This Christmas" is gentle and hopeful, the kind of song you only notice on the third listen and then never forget.
Seventies and eighties rock that deserves a second life
"Christmas Must Be Tonight" by The Band, from 1977, has the feel of a small-town church at midnight. Greg Lake's "I Believe in Father Christmas", from 1975, is grand and a little bittersweet.
Kate Bush's "December Will Be Magic Again", from 1980, is strange and lovely in the way only her songs are. And Queen's "Thank God It's Christmas", from 1984, is the big, warm ending that a mixtape like this deserves.
How to put your Christmas mixtape songs in order
Order matters as much as choice. Open with something upbeat and familiar enough to set the mood, then move into the soul songs, then the playful new wave tracks. Save the quiet songs for the end, when the listener is ready for them.
On a CD you have about 80 minutes, which is roughly twenty songs, as we explain in how many songs fit on a CD. On a cassette, think in two sides: Side A for the party, Side B for the night. Mix one or two songs the person already loves with the ones they have never heard. Recognition makes the discoveries feel safe.
Before you finalize the list, listen to it once from start to finish, ideally in the evening with the lights low. You will hear straight away which song breaks the mood and which transition feels too sudden. Swap one or two, and the whole mix will flow better.
Turn the mix into a Christmas gift
A playlist link gets lost in a group chat by Boxing Day. A CD or cassette with a cover you designed and a handwritten tracklist stays on a shelf for years, and gets played again every December.
Add a short note on the insert explaining why you picked a few of the songs. If you are not sure what to say, these ideas on what to write on a custom cassette or CD insert will help. It also makes a lovely present for the people who are hardest to shop for, like parents who have everything.
The usual songs will still be playing in every shop this December. Yours can be the music someone actually looks forward to. When you are ready, start creating your own mixtape.